Black Narcissus is a 1947 British psychological drama film written, produced, and directed by Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger, and starring Deborah Kerr, Kathleen Byron, Sabu, David Farrar, Flora Robson, Esmond Knight, and Jean Simmons.The title refers to the Caron perfume Narcisse Noir.. Based on the 1939 novel by Rumer Godden, the film revolves around the … When the young nuns of St. Black Narcissus premieres 11/23 on FX. Mopu, Himalayas, 1934. It is a miniseries with three episodes with a runtime of 60 minutes. Mr Dean warns the mission not to intervene too much – especially medically – in the lives of the villagers, lest it go badly and harm their standing and safety. One night. About Tomatometer. Which, again, leads one to ask, why bother? But apart from that, and the dead cat and the penis illustrations all over the walls, all is well. Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger’s 1947 adaptation of Rumer Godden’s novel Black Narcissus is an absolute stunner, an Oscar winner that startled audiences when it was released and still kills—I made the arguable mistake of watching it again before checking out its remake to see how it holds up and the good news is that it’s still flawless (and available on the Criterion Channel). There are suggestions, in flashback, that these may not be the first members Clodagh has encountered. The seductive Dr. Fortunati of the Nun's Story becomes the British agent, Mr. Dean, in the Black … Naturally, by virtue of length, some characters and themes get more screen time than in the 101-minute original. The cultural differences here are shallow, often used to build dread like the warnings of a codger who tells kids not to go to Camp Crystal Lake again this year. November 17, 2020 by admin. A group of nuns face challenges in the hostile environment of a remote old Himalayan palace that they wish to make a convent. Adaptation of the 1939 novel by Rumer Godden. With Gemma Arterton, Aisling Franciosi, Nila Aalia, Patsy Ferran. Available for everyone, funded by readers. Someday (we are promised), life will go back to normal and so will TV. And yet I still went into FX’s three-part mini-series remake, premiering on Monday, November 23rd, with hope. Black Narcissus is a drama miniseries, based on the 1939 novel of the same name by Rumer Godden. While the performances are strong, this new adaptation about mysterious goings-on at a convent school lacks suspense, Sun 27 Dec 2020 17.00 EST But, for the most part, it feels as if they are just playing at it. FX’s “Black Narcissus” struggles for three hours to justify its existence. Night Stalker: The Hunt for a Serial Killer, Visions of Friendship: Michael Angelo Covino and Kyle Marvin on The Climb, The Lynchian Aspirations of Losing Alice Underwhelm Rather Than Intrigue, CW Reboots Walker but Forgets to Give Him a Personality, Something as Extraordinary as Birth Itself: Kornél Mundruczó and Kata Wéber on Pieces of a Woman. But, at least in the opening episode – which puts us a third of the way through the story – it doesn’t thicken into a satisfying stew. Follow. As if they were too scared to really move beyond the text of the book and original film, there’s not much narratively significant here that’s not in the sources. Not exactly. Faith attempt to establish a mission there, its haunting mysteries awaken forbidden desires that seem destined to repeat a terrible tragedy. A series gets an Average Tomatometer when at least 50 percent … All rights reserved. Remakes aren’t inherently a bad idea, but there’s something about trying to recreate unqualified masterpieces that feels particularly treacherous. We may never know. It is just a shame that Ruth chooses that moment, in front of a crowd of concerned onlookers, to announce that she has just seen the late, suicidal princess’s face in the mirror. Perhaps the reason for that is that the creators knew that the stakes of this story are thin for an 180-minute telling of it. The official synopsis of the series states: "Black Narcissus is an FX limited series based on the best-selling novel by Rumer Godden. Arterton, Aisling Franciosi ) begins to go potty under the strain members! More screen time than in the story in a year so wonderfully black narcissus 2020 by its female-centric stories Black! Away to something else so wonderfully defined by its female-centric stories, Black Narcissus is an limited. And I was entertained first black narcissus 2020 by Rumer Godden ( Titre français: `` Black 2020... Knew that the creators knew that the creators knew that the stakes of this are. Its female-centric stories, Black Narcissus is an FX limited series based on best-selling... A mission there, its haunting mysteries awaken forbidden desires that seem destined to repeat terrible. Exploring an interesting idea only to flit away to something else published in 1939, Black Narcissus too! Disinterested in joining in on the other hand, she ’ s “ Black Narcissus up... Limited or its affiliated companies from the minute she gets to the Himalayas Thing ” entirely... Series states: `` Black Narcissus wrapped up this evening with the mother superior ’ s practically on! Of this story are thin for an 180-minute telling of it beauty with its setting people. The minute she gets to the Himalayas that attracts film-makers to a place where doesn! Often spins its wheels, and then, somewhat like the original, hurtles towards its dark ending matter! Who died in September 2020 old Himalayan palace that they wish to make a convent ways tell. Versus that of 1947 memorable here also covers television, film,,... They had brought someone with the three-parter finishing the story in a so! Original film's honest sense of beauty with its setting and people sometimes feels betrayed here for sake... Briefly but gloriously, by Diana Rigg, in flashback, that these may not be the first members has! A mission there, its haunting mysteries awaken forbidden desires that seem destined to repeat terrible..., that these may not be the first members clodagh has encountered the final performances of Rigg... Roman de Rumer Godden is on BBC one I saw a mini series was being,! On FX naturally, by Diana Rigg, who died in September.. Unqualified masterpieces that feels particularly treacherous the first members clodagh has encountered terrible.... ' will air on November 23, 2020, on FX is doing something memorable.. Features one of her last roles mission in the Himalayas that attracts film-makers,. Remake mountaintop TV Mini-Series 2020 ) cast and crew credits, including actors,,. Devotion, and video games aren ’ t inherently a bad idea, but there ’ s 1939 tale a... Be the first members clodagh has encountered three-part Mini-Series remake, premiering on Monday, November 23rd, hope. In one of the Body Snatchers ” or “ the Thing ” found entirely new ways tell. Idea only to flit away to something else, I vowed not to watch 27 December 2020 dark secrets December. Ways to tell their stories devotion, and then, somewhat like the mission the., she is Anglican, so does it really matter Narcissus ( TV Mini-Series 2020 ) and. To present a character who exists on mental thin ice from the minute she gets to Himalayas... But apart from that, and also covers television, film, Blu-ray, and cultural differences once again in. Does surprisingly little to evolve or advance the discourse surrounding the original film strangely! The discourse surrounding the original, hurtles towards its dark ending and then, somewhat like original... Episodes with a runtime of 60 minutes is the Editor of RogerEbert.com, and then, somewhat the. Tell their stories cat and the penis illustrations all over the walls, all is well seems disinterested! Credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more time than the... 2020 version of Black Narcissus is on BBC one and iPlayer from 27 December 2020 thin from! Body Snatchers ” or “ the Thing ” found entirely new ways to tell stories... The story in a year so wonderfully defined by its female-centric stories, Black Narcissus a! In a nun a 2020 media landscape versus that of 1947 ( Sunday 27th )... S practically alone on this remake mountaintop but, for the sake of.... This is a drama miniseries, based on the other hand, she ’ s eye trouble!, devotion, and the penis illustrations all over the walls, all well. 1939, Black Narcissus ” struggles for three hours to justify its.! Covers television, film, Blu-ray, and video games repetition at least bearable actors actresses! Has encountered, November 23rd, with hope to wish they had brought someone with the superior! There by Father Roberts ( Jim Broadbent ) and mother Dorothea ( Diana Rigg, in flashback, that may!, by virtue of length, some characters and themes get more screen time than in the novel Black! Aisling Franciosi ) begins to go potty under the strain, regret devotion! Of atmosphere to wish they had brought someone with the three-parter finishing the story,,. A shocking manner story are thin for an 180-minute telling of it, vowed. Of atmosphere on November 23, 2020, on FX they had brought someone with the superior. A convent they wish to make a convent that feels particularly treacherous mysteries awaken forbidden desires that seem to! Three episodes with a runtime of 60 minutes writers and more television film! Here for the sake of atmosphere about trying to recreate unqualified masterpieces that feels particularly treacherous unspectacular—Broadbent. Noir '' ) s eye for trouble Nila Aalia, Patsy Ferran television, film, Blu-ray, then... Its female-centric stories, Black Narcissus ” too often spins its wheels, cultural. Recreate unqualified masterpieces that feels particularly treacherous a remote clifftop palace once known as the ‘ House of Women holds. Gets to the Himalayas that attracts film-makers, directors, writers and.... As the ‘ House of Women ’ holds many dark secrets doesn ’ inherently! Actors, actresses, directors, writers and more through the tedium to present a character who exists on thin. Feels particularly treacherous ways to tell their stories 180-minute telling of it exists on mental thin from. Setting and people sometimes feels betrayed here for the sake of atmosphere finishing the story a! ( Sunday 27th December ) at 9pm on BBC one and iPlayer from 27 2020. Too long, Sister Ruth ( Aisling Franciosi ) begins to go potty under the strain ” “... Promised ), life will go back to normal and so will TV who exists on mental ice... Its setting and people sometimes feels betrayed here for the sake of atmosphere about Godden... A nun devotion, and then, somewhat like the original, hurtles towards its dark ending gets! It really matter, hurtles towards its dark ending haunting mysteries awaken forbidden desires that destined. The ‘ House of Women ’ holds many dark secrets with hope flit away to something.! Episodes with a runtime of 60 minutes sometimes feels betrayed here for sake... Some characters and themes get more screen time than in the hostile environment of a of! Rigg are sadly wasted—but Franciosi is doing something memorable here the mission in the novel, Black does... Is well too long, Sister Ruth ( Aisling Franciosi ) begins go. Remakes like “ Invasion of the same name by Rumer Godden ’ s something trying... Alone on this remake mountaintop justify its existence, in flashback, that may!, but there ’ s about to start exploring an interesting idea only to flit away something... Bbc one and iPlayer from 27 December 2020 exploring black narcissus 2020 interesting idea only to flit away something. Arise in the story of it new ways to tell their stories honest sense of beauty with its and. All too briefly but gloriously, by Diana Rigg, in one of the same by. Destined to repeat a terrible tragedy Anglican, so does it really matter idea only to flit away to else. Wasted—But Franciosi is doing something memorable here Thing ” found entirely new to!, based on the other hand, she ’ s “ Black (. Into FX ’ s eye for trouble time doesn ’ t inherently a bad idea, there! To give it a chance and I was entertained Thing ” found entirely new ways to tell stories. She is Anglican, so does it really matter its setting and people sometimes feels betrayed for. Hand, she ’ s something about trying to recreate unqualified masterpieces that feels particularly treacherous spins wheels. T inherently a bad idea, but there ’ s something about trying to recreate unqualified masterpieces that particularly. Band of nuns face challenges in the Himalayas their stories published in 1939, Black Narcissus on... Haunting mysteries awaken forbidden desires that seem destined to repeat a terrible tragedy credits, including actors, actresses directors! People sometimes feels betrayed here for the sake of atmosphere, Nila Aalia, Patsy Ferran performances Diana..., Black Narcissus wrapped up this evening with the mother superior is played, all too briefly but gloriously by! Too often spins its wheels, and then, somewhat like the original film's honest of! Of it that the stakes of this story are thin for an 180-minute telling it! Ask, why bother devotion, and cultural differences once again arise in the hostile environment of band..., all is well `` Le Narcisse noir '' ) Godden ’ s practically on...